News for Queer Women

Medical Groups Back Bid to Block Washington’s Anti-Trans Athlete Ban and Sex-Testing Rule

girl playing softball
Photo via Pixabay

The initiative is already being challenged in court by Washington nonprofits and families.

The largest medical organizations in Washington state have come out in support of a lawsuit challenging a recent anti-trans youth initiative passed by voters in the recent midterm election. 

Initiative 638 would force girls to undergo examinations over their sex assigned at birth, in order for them to play on school sports teams. Boys are not required to do this.

“As statewide medical organizations, we are deeply troubled by the initiative’s mandate imposing medically unnecessary examinations and verification requirements on girls participating in school sports,” the Washington State Medical Association along with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists – Washington Section, the Washington Academy of Family Physicians, the Washington Academy of Physician Associates, the Washington Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Washington Chapter of the American College of Physicians, and the Washington State Psychiatric Association said in a joint press release.

The initiative goes into effect on December 3, the same day a judge will hear a request for a preliminary injunction that would block it.

“Without more time to develop statewide guidance, physicians and other clinicians face difficult professional and ethical questions about how to comply with the initiative’s requirements while maintaining accepted standards of care. Implementing these requirements in the middle of the school year as students prepare for winter sports creates unnecessary challenges for students, families, schools, and the overall healthcare system,” the groups say.

Washington nonprofits and families filed their lawsuit challenging the approved law soon after the election earlier this month.

The plaintiffs in the case include TransFamilies, a nonprofit organization based in Washington state that works to support families with transgender and gender-diverse children; the Washington Education Association (WEA), a statewide union that represents more than 90,000 educators; and the parents of students who play girls’ sports in public schools.

There are three ways that girls can “verify” their sex, according to the ACLU of Washington: “through the student’s reproductive anatomy, their genetic makeup, or their normal endogenously produced testosterone levels.”

A November 18 request for the injunction shared with GO makes three constitutional claims. It says the verification rule violates the state Equal Rights Amendment because it applies only to girls. It says the rule intrudes on students’ privacy without legal authority. And it also says the initiative changes existing anti-discrimination laws without setting them out, as the constitution requires.

The plaintiffs have asked the court to strike down the entire initiative, or block it until a ruling is delivered in the case. “Neither the intrusion into students’ privacy nor the loss of athletic opportunities can be undone by a later judgment,” the motion states.

According to the motion, the initiative doesn’t define what verification involves. It cites physicians’ declarations saying genital exams aren’t part of sports physicals, and that hormone and chromosome tests require blood draws, cost money and likely wouldn’t be covered by insurance.

“Sports give young people a place to make friends and be part of a team, but Initiative 638 seeks to deny transgender girls those opportunities,” said Adrien Leavitt, staff attorney for the ACLU of Washington, when the lawsuit was announced. “Washington has long had strong protections against discrimination. We will fight to stop this law from taking effect and prevent this needless attack on youth in our state.”

Seattle Public Schools have also come out against the initiative. 

“Washington has important laws that protect student privacy, guarantee equal access to educational opportunities, and ensure students are treated fairly,” said Seattle School Board Member-at-Large Joe Mizrahi in a statement. “Right now, we don’t see a way to implement Initiative 638 without violating those vital protections. We aren’t willing to simply disregard our other legal obligations, and that’s why we’re asking the courts to help resolve this conflict.” 

Meanwhile, a “biological sex attestation” form for winter-sport girls in grades 7–12 is due December 3, according to public radio station KUOW. Students without it can practice but not compete.