News for Queer Women

Supreme Court Won’t Hear Anti-Trans Hate Group’s Claim That Misgendering Is Protected Speech

U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C.
U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. Photo by Mark Stebnicki/Pexels

Gays Against Groomers sued Colorado lawmakers after its activist’s anti-trans testimony was cut off after he wouldn’t stop misgendering someone.

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected a case brought in part by an activist from Gays Against Groomers (GAG), which argued the First Amendment protected his refusal to use a transgender woman’s pronouns while testifying before Colorado lawmakers in 2024.

The Southern Poverty Law Center-designated hate group said in the suit, Gays Against Groomers, et al. v. Garcia, et al., that Colorado lawmakers had stopped their testimony after they refused to use the correct pronouns in reference to a trans woman who had a bill named after her.

The court denied the petition without comment, as it typically does. It leaves in place a decision by a lower court to dismiss the suit against several Colorado lawmakers.

A court initially dismissed the lawsuit in 2024, according to The Advocate.

An appeals court “upheld that decision in March, finding that legislative immunity protected lawmakers’ authority to establish and enforce hearing rules,” the outlet reports.

Rich Guggenheim of GAG and Christina Goeke of Rocky Mountain Women’s Network were testifying against Tiara’s law in early 2024, which is a state law that allows trans people with felony convictions to more easily change their names.

According to Colorado Newsline, Colorado’s HB-1071 was named for Tiara Latrice Kelley, a transgender woman in Colorado Springs. Under a provision of Florida law, her three misdemeanor charges there for past sex work were raised to a felony. Before the law, someone with a felony conviction has to show a judge “good cause” before legally changing their name. The bill added gender-affirming care to what counts as good cause. This now lets trans people convicted under a former name ask a court to approve a name change and update records like driver’s licenses.

As a survivor of the Club Q shooting in 2022, Kelley could not access survivor funds because of documents in her former name, according to the outlet.

The anti-trans activists alleged in their suit that Democratic lawmakers had said they would need to use “respectful discourse” and to not use “derogatory language” or misgender witnesses.

They refused, and according to LGBTQ Nation, their testimony ended.

The activists sued over their testimony with the support of the Institute for Free Speech.

The law was passed and signed by out Colorado Gov. Jared Polis.

“I am really glad that future generations of trans people like myself have one less thing to worry about when trying to affirm their identity,” Kelley said after the bill was passed, according to LGBTQ Nation. “I feel honored, I feel amazed, I feel proud of our legislators here in Colorado – most of them, at least.”

In the lawsuit, Guggenheim and Goeke said that they were censored because they didn’t support “transgenderism” or participate in the “pronoun ritual.”

“We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case,” said Institute for Free Speech Senior Attorney Del Kolde, the lead litigator in the case, in a statement. He added that it was “bad for free expression.”