News for Queer Women

Idaho Bill Advances – Parents To Be Notified If Minors Use “Pronouns, Appearance, Or Dress” Not Corresponding To “Individual’s Sex”

The “Pediatric Secretive Transitions Parental Rights Act” would require schools, healthcare and child care providers to notify parents if child adopts “a name, pronouns, appearance, or dress that does not correspond to the individual’s sex.”

Featured Image: (Photo by RDB/ullstein bild via Getty Images)

Lawmakers with trans folks in their cross-hairs have been busy in Idaho. Last Friday, March 25, the state passed the most restrictive bathroom law in the nation – with possible prison sentences for trans people using bathrooms, locker rooms and changing rooms that align with their gender identity. The weekend hardly broke, before legislators were at it again. On Monday, March 30, following the House’s lead, the Idaho Senate passed House Bill 822, forcing teachers and doctors to out transitioning minors to their parents.

Next stop: Governor Brad Little’s desk where the bill could be signed into law with the stroke of a pen.

“It is the intent of the legislature to prohibit any health care provider or educational institution from facilitating a pediatric sex transition or social transition without informing and obtaining informed consent from a minor child’s parents or guardians,” the recently-amended bill states.

“‘Social transition’ means the process by which an individual goes from identifying with and living as a gender that corresponds to the individual’s sex to identifying with and living as a gender different from the individual’s sex and may involve social, legal, or physical changes, including adopting a name, pronouns, appearance, or dress that does not correspond to the individual’s sex.”

It is unclear from this language what constitutes appearance or dress corresponding to one’s sex. Will girls only be permitted skirts and bonnets? Would longer hair on a boy constitute “physical change?” We can’t know who will police the fashion, but with this law, everyone gets policed.

Restricted: Idaho Targets Trans People Using Private Business Bathrooms – New Law, Prison Possible

Use of restrooms, changing rooms, overnight lodging and participation in sports teams also get air time in the bill. A minor student’s parent must be notified within 72 hours of “receiving any request by the minor student to participate in or facilitate the social transition of the minor student.” Such requests include the use of nicknames. And while the word “request” is mentioned in a single sentence of this multi-page bill, the entirety of the mandate can easily be interpreted as centered more around observation at its best, surveillance at its worst.

The Attorney General (seemingly lacking more pressing matters) may investigate the above offenses, and seek up to $100,000 for violations. Parents (“aggrieved persons”) can sue schools, healthcare providers and institutions deemed to be assisting or facilitating with these transitions. Courts can order institutions to comply.

The coda to this measure? An “emergency” has been declared (not to be confused with a declaration of state of emergency, like the Idaho wildfires of 2013, or the 1983 Borah Peak earthquake).